Essay about Assessment of Descartes Claims About the...

Assessment of Descartes Claims About the Existence of God While reading Descartes book â€Å"meditations on the first philosophy† I noticed some fatal flaws in his reasoning in his 3rd mediation, so I shall start from the start of this chapter and assess his reasoning’s as I read through the chapter. Descartes assesses that he is certain he is a thinking thing, as I think therefore I am is self-evident, he then tries to go on to see whatever else he can be certain about! He notices with â€Å"I am a thinking thing† he has a â€Å"clear and distinct perception of what he is asserting†, He then turns this around and states that things that he clearly and distinctly perceives are true, and if anything he†¦show more content†¦Thus these ideas could be his own, or innate. He also states that an infinite god has more objective reality in it than a finite being. Well this would be true, if god existed because we’d be limited in comparison to god because god is perfect and he contains infinite qualities, which makes infinite qualities perfect then infinite would be a higher/greater quality than finite, but Descartes has not proved god exists, and so cannot infer from gods existence that infinity is of greater perfection than the finite. Descartes claims ideas regress from one another till they reach absolute perfection, and Descartes suspects that if ideas are too perfect for him, then they must had originated from something more perfect that him. He uses these ideas to ‘prove’ the existence of god, Descartes states that god has various qualities he’s infinite, independent, supremely intelligent, supremely powerful and which created both myself and everything else, these ideas are so perfect he claims that the more he concentrates on them, the less possible it seems that they could have originated from him alone. He thus concludes god exists! Descartes is supposing that the idea of god necessarily comes because of the regression of ideas must go down to perfection and because God is perfection and perfection isShow MoreRelatedLogic, Metaphysics, Epistemology, And The Value Theory1244 Words   |  5 Pagesworld is actually real ⠁Æ' what something really is ⠁Æ' how we come to understand what something is ⠁Æ' why something is what it is ⠁Æ' Ontology answers questions of: ⠁Æ' existence ⠁Æ' being ⠁Æ' how actuals are essentially existing †¢ The division of epistemology is the branch of Philosophy that determines how we came about knowledge we ve obtained, the restrictions humans have when obtaining knowledge, and the way we as humans know how to group our knowledge as truth or falsity. This part of PhilosophyRead MoreA Review Of Protagoras Epistemology1399 Words   |  6 Pagesalso makes a connection between Theaetetus’ answer and the answer of an earlier Sophist: Well, you have delivered yourself of a very important doctrine about knowledge; it is indeed the opinion of Protagoras, who has another way of expressing it. Man, he says, is the measure of all things, of the existence of things that are, and of the non-existence of things that are not.2 1 Plato, Theaetetus, 151d. 2 Plato, Theaetetus,, 151d. Phillips !2 Socrates, never a fan of the Sophists, sought to address theRead More The Free Will in Meditations on First Philosophy by Descartes3767 Words   |  16 PagesFree Will in Meditations on First Philosophy by Descartes I In Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes takes the reader through a methodological exercise in philosophical enquiry. After stripping the intellect of all doubtful and false beliefs, he re-examines the nature and structure of being in an attempt to secure a universally valid epistemology free from skepticism. Hoping for the successful reconciliation of science and theology, Descartes works to reconstruct a new foundation of absoluteRead MoreThe Theory Of Knowledge And Perceptions2059 Words   |  9 PagesIn his first mediation Descartes comes to the conclusion that there is not one of his former beliefs about which a doubt may not properly be raised. I will assess his reasons for thinking this to be so. I will look at the variety of reasons he gives in relation to: his senses, the dreaming argument, what is real and what isn’t, God, his opinions and his evil demon argument. Through assessing these epistemological (theory of knowledge) arguments I will conclude that in o rder to obtain new perceptionsRead MoreModernity and Nietzsche Essay1994 Words   |  8 Pagescenturies philosophers have tried to explain the nature of reality and the order that exists within the universe around us. The purpose of this paper is to first trace the developments that led up to modernity. Next I will react to the claim made by Fredrick Nietzsche that â€Å"God is dead† from a Biblical perspective. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Philosophers have attempted to answer that question of what reality is and how to answer the questions that everyone faced. The first philosopher Thales held thatRead More Comparing Saint Augustine and Charles Taylors Ideas of Authenticity5579 Words   |  23 Pagesimportance of some moral measurement system. Taylor claims that St. Augustine initiated a concept of inwardness, a turning towards the inner self to find truth and the idea of authenticity is simply a further development of Augustine’s inwardness. In this paper I will discuss in detail Taylor’s idea of authenticity: the pros and cons. I will lay out some of his arguments as to why he thinks this idea originated with Augustine. I will talk about Augustine’s view on the inner man and how this is connectedRead MoreCharles Taylor, Augustine and the Ethics of Authenticity5646 Words   |  23 Pagesimportance of some moral measurement system. Taylor claims that St. Augustine initiated a concept of inwardness, a turning towards the inner self to find truth and the idea of authenticity is simply a further development of Augustines inwardness. In this paper I will discuss in detail Taylors idea of authenticity: the pros and cons. I will lay out some of his arguments as to why he thinks this idea originated with Augustine. I will talk about Augustines view on the inner man and how this is connectedRead More The Limits of Science Essays3754 Words   |  16 PagesScientists say no. Philosophers are divided in their response. The humanities say that science is not humanitarian, and thus not metaphysically deep. In response, scientists and some philosophers contend that science is the best knowledge we have about the world. I argue that science is limited by its form. Science has no object that derives from the human form. Everything that is incomparable to the dimension of the human body is reducible to notions that are com mensurable to that body. This phenomenologicallyRead MoreMental Health Counseling6134 Words   |  25 Pagestechniques used within both forms of this type of counseling. Psychology did not emerge as a separate discipline until the late 1800’s; this discipline can be traced back to its earliest history of the early Greeks (Kendra). During the 17th century Rene Descartes, a French Philosopher, introduced the idea of dualism, which asserted that the mind and the body were two separate entities that interact to form the human experience and psychology was born (Kendra). Mental health counseling and community counselingRead MoreHow Fa Has the Use of English Language Enriched or Disrupted Life and Culture in Mauritius15928 Words   |  64 Pagesads not by this site [pic] [pic] ENGL 103A: American Literature 1789-1900 (Archived) Dept of English, UC Santa Barbara (Summer 2011) †¢ ABOUT †¢ ASSIGNMENTS †¢ SYLLABUS †¢ DISCUSSION †¢ CLOSE READINGS CLOSE READINGS Post your close reading posts here. Share this: †¢ Twitter †¢ Facebook †¢ Like this: Like Loading... [pic] 26 Comments on â€Å"CLOSE READINGS† 1. [pic]John Cooper says: July 13, 2011 at 3:36 pm Emily Dickenson’s poem â€Å"Because